CPT "Regina Pacis" published the reasons for the conviction of Don Cesare Lodeserto and his staff ........... .................................................. ............ by conviction of Don Cesare Lodeserto ... Having held by the defendants' conduct described is the use of physical violence to force people to endure insults and humiliating constraints in the causation of injuries, can not be classified in terms of abuse of means of correction, but in terms of domestic violence and aggravated injury , crimes belonging to the knowledge of the single judge in court. The offense under Article. 571 cp is embodied in the conduct of those who abuse the means of correction or discipline to the detriment of a person under his authority or entrusted to him by reason of education, education, care, supervision or custody determinando un pericolo di malattia nel corpo o
nella mente, con l´ulteriore specificazione che la causazione di
lesioni personali o della morte aggrava la fattispecie ed il
trattamento sanzionatorio.
Dunque, l´abuso dei mezzi di correzione non è altro che una
enfatizzazione oltre il limite consentito delle modalità
educative e disciplinari idonee a determinare il pericolo
dell´insorgere di una malattia fisica o mentale.
L´interpretazione giurisprudenziale della disposizione in
questione ha chiarito che integra la fattispecie criminosa di
cui all´art. 571 c.p. "l´uso in funzione educativa del mezzo
astrattamente lecito, sia esso di natura fisica, psicologica o
morale, che trasmodi nell´abuso sia in ragione dell´arbitrarietà
o inappropriate timing of its application, either because of the excess of the measure, but does not draw on forms of violence "(Cass. Pen. Sec. VI 07/11/1997, Straw), stating that" the term <> is taken as synonymous with education and assumes that these resources ... can form a legitimate and permissible use that, however, transcends measure to a significant excess, it becomes illegal, thus complementing the shape of the abuse "(Cass. pen. Sec. VI 01/09/2004, No. 4934). He also clarified that" excess of non-violent means of correcting this case falls within the art. 571 cp although rectum dall'animus juvenile offenders "(Cass. pen. Sec. VI 05.16.1996, No 4904) as" the use violence can never be regarded as aimed at re-education purposes " (Cass. pen. Sec. VI 10/26/2004, No. 44621). Moreover, in order to determine whether this constitutes the criminal case under Article. 571 cp need to examine not only the objective element of the individual case and, therefore, the correlation between the means and methods and educational purpose and discipline, but also the subjective element that is the reason that the agent has determined that disciplinary or corrective ( Cass. pen. Sec. VI, 04.11.1996, Coal). An examination of judicial interpretation can fully understand the structure of the crime and the real essence of that in terms of the legal page. 29 protected, as well as to demonstrate that the conduct described in the book are that can be classified under the category of crime and punishment provided by art. 571 cp Having traced the offended people in the CTP savagely beaten, ridiculed and treated like animals, forcing them with unprecedented violence to swallow pieces of raw pork in the full knowledge that characterized the Muslim faith, which is why this type of meat, more during the period of Ramadan, it was absolutely forbidden, it can not be a means of educational and corrective, as is embodied in a wholly gratuitous violence and abject. I can not really find the purpose of correction in condotte che sono state ampiamente descritte; è, invece,
del tutto evidente che l´unico motivo che ha determinato gli
agenti è stato quello punitivo della violenza, della
prevaricazione e dell´umiliazione , ferendo nel corpo e
nell´animo soggetti disperati colpevoli solo di aver tentato una
fuga.
Pertanto, oltre alle lesioni ampiamente certificate in
atti, è chiaro che l´aver costretto a subire comportamenti quali
quelli della costrizione a mangiare carne di maiale, o il non
averli impediti, e le derisioni per il solo fatto di aderire ad
un credo religioso non può che integrare il delitto di violenza
privata.
In proposito, la Suprema Corte precisa che "l'abuso dei
mezzi correction or discipline, provided for and punished by Article 571 of the Cp, presupposes a lawful and permitted use of the media, turned upwards in offense (abuse): consequently the offense is not configurable when resources are used per se illegal , by their nature or even the potential for damage to person or psyche, having in this case the criminal conduct be attributed to the assumptions made with the aforementioned means (voluntary personal injury, domestic violence, abuse). (In this case, the Supreme Court considered the proper decision regarding domestic violence that had characterized as the policy initiated by the leaders of a Boy Scout camp, who, to punish a child entrusted to them, had inflicted a humiliating and degrading punishment, which is characterized by the use of violence, consisted in having tied to a concrete pile with a rope, the sprinkle of sauce and dishwashing liquid waste, and making him the subject Finally, a water jet pump; TO, according to the court of conduct characterized by the use of violence as such can not be traced, even in terms of abuse, the concept of "correction", this being understood to mean of "education" and then not being able to pursue any goal of education through the use of a tool that would contradict the fundamental values \u200b\u200bof peace and respect that should characterize the human contribution) " (Cass. pen. Sec. V, 11.05.2002, No. 36842, Iacono and others). With the crime of domestic violence contributes to more severe injuries pursuant to art. 61 n. 4 cp for having used torture and acted with cruelty to persons. In order to injuries, as mentioned above, documentation certifying health acts, along with all other emergency investigation, the existence of the crime. There is no doubt as to the configurability dell'aggravante which occurs whenever the agent inflicts suffering to the victim who falls outside the normal process of p.. 30 causation of the event, characterized by free and occasioned by a particularly reprehensible conduct, a symptom of anxiety same agent to satisfy its desire to cause pain. The reading of the evidence makes palpable in all its shocking evidence such as injuries caused to persons offenses were accompanied by their willingness to inflict torture and suffering to the victims for the sheer pleasure of seeing them suffer. are not otherwise explained how violent acts, the derision (Vieru in Salem: "Where is Allah who can save you and protect you now?" - Mohamed Salem deposition, hearing Minutes 04.03.2003) the fury beat in the fugitives, while still keeping them on with a club were forced to eat pork. ................................................. .................................................. ..... .................................................. .................................................. ... PQM beds Articles. 533 and 535 cpp, Lodeserto Caesar declares guilty of crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp ., So differently trained and contested the facts as described in the phonebook, Lodeserto Joseph (aka Luke), Vieru Natalia (aka Natasha) DOKAJ Paulin (Paul said), except for incidents against Agrebi and Aidi GOZLUGOL Husevin, except for the incident against Tarconni, MARA and Armando SEN Ramazan guilty of crimes under Articles. 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp, so differently trained the facts as alleged and described in the phonebook, Francesco D'AMBROSIO, HOTEL, Vito, Vito OTTOMAN, THIGH Michele, Vito APPLES, Pierre Mario and fumaroles John guilty of crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp, so differently trained and contested the facts as described in p.. 39 section and, in competition with extenuating circumstances for all offenders deemed equivalent to the alleged aggravating circumstances, sentenced to death Cesare Lodeserto one year and four months 'imprisonment, Lodeserto Joseph Vieru Natalia penalty of one year and two months' imprisonment, DOKAJ, GOZLUGOL, MARA SEN and the penalty of nine months imprisonment, D'AMBROSIO and Ottoman Empires to the punishment of one year and four months in prison, hotel, PIERRO, fumaroles and thigh to the punishment of one year in prison, in addition to paying the costs. Bedding Articles. Cpp 533 and 535, said John ROBERTI and fuck Anna Catia guilty of the crime being prosecuted, and competition for extenuating circumstances, each sentenced to nine months' imprisonment penalty, in addition to paying the costs. Suspended sentence under the conditions of the law for all defendants. Read Article. 530 cpp, carry out all the defendants in relation to crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, so differently trained and contested the facts as described in rubrica, con
riferimento agli episodi relativi ad HADDAJI Mohammed, perché il
fatto non sussiste.
Letto l´art. 530 c.p.p., assolve LODESERTO Cesare e DOKAJ
Paulin dai reati di cui agli artt. 40, 110, 610, 582 e 585, in
relazione agli artt. 577 e 61 n. 4 c.p., così diversamente
qualificati i fatti come descritti e contestati in rubrica, con
riferimento agli episodi relativi ad Agrebi Baligh e Aidi
Manjoub per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letto l´art. 530 cpv c.p.p., assolve D´EPIRO Alessandro,
BLASI Francesco e CASAFINA Antonio dai reati di cui agli artt.
40, 110, 610, 582 e 585, in relazione agli artt. 577 e 61 n. 4
c.p., così diversamente qualificati i fatti come descritti e
contestati in rubrica, per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letto l´art. 530 c.p.p., assolve LODESERTO Cesare e
LODESERTO Giuseppe dal reato loro ascritto al capo B della
rubrica per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letti gli artt. 538 e ss c.p.p., condanna LODESERTO Cesare,
LODESERTO Giuseppe (detto Luca), VIERU Natalia (detta Natasha),
DOKAJ Paulin (detto Paolo), GOZLUGOL Husevin, MARA Armando e
SEN Ramazan, D´AMBROSIO Francesco, ALBERGA Vito, OTTOMANO Vito,
COSCIA Michele, MELE Vito, DI PIERRO Mario e FUMAROLA Giovanni
al risarcimento dei danni patiti dalle parti civili costituite,
fatta eccezione per Haddaji Mohammed, e con esclusione di Agrebi
Baligh e Aidi Manjoub con esclusivo riferimento a Lodeserto
Cesare e Dokaj Paulin, da liquidarsi in separato giudizio.
Condanna gli imputati al pagamento di una provvisionale pari
a € 2000 per ogni parte civile costituita, eccezion fatta per
l´Associazione Studi Giuridici sull´Immigrazione (ASGI).
Pone a carico degli imputati le spese di costituzione e
rappresentanza delle parti civili che liquida in euro 5000 per
la parte civile assistita dall´Avv. Pistelli, euro 7000 per le
parti civili assistite dall´Avv. Petrelli, euro 15000 per le
parti civili assistite dall´Avv. Petrelli, oltre IVA, CA e spese
forfetizzate come per legge.
Letto l´art. 544 comma 3 c.p.p., indica in novanta giorni il
termine per il deposito della motivazione.
Lecce, 22 luglio 2005
_____________ ____
nella mente, con l´ulteriore specificazione che la causazione di
lesioni personali o della morte aggrava la fattispecie ed il
trattamento sanzionatorio.
Dunque, l´abuso dei mezzi di correzione non è altro che una
enfatizzazione oltre il limite consentito delle modalità
educative e disciplinari idonee a determinare il pericolo
dell´insorgere di una malattia fisica o mentale.
L´interpretazione giurisprudenziale della disposizione in
questione ha chiarito che integra la fattispecie criminosa di
cui all´art. 571 c.p. "l´uso in funzione educativa del mezzo
astrattamente lecito, sia esso di natura fisica, psicologica o
morale, che trasmodi nell´abuso sia in ragione dell´arbitrarietà
o inappropriate timing of its application, either because of the excess of the measure, but does not draw on forms of violence "(Cass. Pen. Sec. VI 07/11/1997, Straw), stating that" the term <
del tutto evidente che l´unico motivo che ha determinato gli
agenti è stato quello punitivo della violenza, della
prevaricazione e dell´umiliazione , ferendo nel corpo e
nell´animo soggetti disperati colpevoli solo di aver tentato una
fuga.
Pertanto, oltre alle lesioni ampiamente certificate in
atti, è chiaro che l´aver costretto a subire comportamenti quali
quelli della costrizione a mangiare carne di maiale, o il non
averli impediti, e le derisioni per il solo fatto di aderire ad
un credo religioso non può che integrare il delitto di violenza
privata.
In proposito, la Suprema Corte precisa che "l'abuso dei
mezzi correction or discipline, provided for and punished by Article 571 of the Cp, presupposes a lawful and permitted use of the media, turned upwards in offense (abuse): consequently the offense is not configurable when resources are used per se illegal , by their nature or even the potential for damage to person or psyche, having in this case the criminal conduct be attributed to the assumptions made with the aforementioned means (voluntary personal injury, domestic violence, abuse). (In this case, the Supreme Court considered the proper decision regarding domestic violence that had characterized as the policy initiated by the leaders of a Boy Scout camp, who, to punish a child entrusted to them, had inflicted a humiliating and degrading punishment, which is characterized by the use of violence, consisted in having tied to a concrete pile with a rope, the sprinkle of sauce and dishwashing liquid waste, and making him the subject Finally, a water jet pump; TO, according to the court of conduct characterized by the use of violence as such can not be traced, even in terms of abuse, the concept of "correction", this being understood to mean of "education" and then not being able to pursue any goal of education through the use of a tool that would contradict the fundamental values \u200b\u200bof peace and respect that should characterize the human contribution) " (Cass. pen. Sec. V, 11.05.2002, No. 36842, Iacono and others). With the crime of domestic violence contributes to more severe injuries pursuant to art. 61 n. 4 cp for having used torture and acted with cruelty to persons. In order to injuries, as mentioned above, documentation certifying health acts, along with all other emergency investigation, the existence of the crime. There is no doubt as to the configurability dell'aggravante which occurs whenever the agent inflicts suffering to the victim who falls outside the normal process of p.. 30 causation of the event, characterized by free and occasioned by a particularly reprehensible conduct, a symptom of anxiety same agent to satisfy its desire to cause pain. The reading of the evidence makes palpable in all its shocking evidence such as injuries caused to persons offenses were accompanied by their willingness to inflict torture and suffering to the victims for the sheer pleasure of seeing them suffer. are not otherwise explained how violent acts, the derision (Vieru in Salem: "Where is Allah who can save you and protect you now?" - Mohamed Salem deposition, hearing Minutes 04.03.2003) the fury beat in the fugitives, while still keeping them on with a club were forced to eat pork. ................................................. .................................................. ..... .................................................. .................................................. ... PQM beds Articles. 533 and 535 cpp, Lodeserto Caesar declares guilty of crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp ., So differently trained and contested the facts as described in the phonebook, Lodeserto Joseph (aka Luke), Vieru Natalia (aka Natasha) DOKAJ Paulin (Paul said), except for incidents against Agrebi and Aidi GOZLUGOL Husevin, except for the incident against Tarconni, MARA and Armando SEN Ramazan guilty of crimes under Articles. 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp, so differently trained the facts as alleged and described in the phonebook, Francesco D'AMBROSIO, HOTEL, Vito, Vito OTTOMAN, THIGH Michele, Vito APPLES, Pierre Mario and fumaroles John guilty of crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, unified under Article. 81 cp, so differently trained and contested the facts as described in p.. 39 section and, in competition with extenuating circumstances for all offenders deemed equivalent to the alleged aggravating circumstances, sentenced to death Cesare Lodeserto one year and four months 'imprisonment, Lodeserto Joseph Vieru Natalia penalty of one year and two months' imprisonment, DOKAJ, GOZLUGOL, MARA SEN and the penalty of nine months imprisonment, D'AMBROSIO and Ottoman Empires to the punishment of one year and four months in prison, hotel, PIERRO, fumaroles and thigh to the punishment of one year in prison, in addition to paying the costs. Bedding Articles. Cpp 533 and 535, said John ROBERTI and fuck Anna Catia guilty of the crime being prosecuted, and competition for extenuating circumstances, each sentenced to nine months' imprisonment penalty, in addition to paying the costs. Suspended sentence under the conditions of the law for all defendants. Read Article. 530 cpp, carry out all the defendants in relation to crimes under Articles. 40, 110, 610, 582 and 585, in conjunction with Articles. 61 n. 577; 4 cp, so differently trained and contested the facts as described in rubrica, con
riferimento agli episodi relativi ad HADDAJI Mohammed, perché il
fatto non sussiste.
Letto l´art. 530 c.p.p., assolve LODESERTO Cesare e DOKAJ
Paulin dai reati di cui agli artt. 40, 110, 610, 582 e 585, in
relazione agli artt. 577 e 61 n. 4 c.p., così diversamente
qualificati i fatti come descritti e contestati in rubrica, con
riferimento agli episodi relativi ad Agrebi Baligh e Aidi
Manjoub per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letto l´art. 530 cpv c.p.p., assolve D´EPIRO Alessandro,
BLASI Francesco e CASAFINA Antonio dai reati di cui agli artt.
40, 110, 610, 582 e 585, in relazione agli artt. 577 e 61 n. 4
c.p., così diversamente qualificati i fatti come descritti e
contestati in rubrica, per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letto l´art. 530 c.p.p., assolve LODESERTO Cesare e
LODESERTO Giuseppe dal reato loro ascritto al capo B della
rubrica per non aver commesso il fatto.
Letti gli artt. 538 e ss c.p.p., condanna LODESERTO Cesare,
LODESERTO Giuseppe (detto Luca), VIERU Natalia (detta Natasha),
DOKAJ Paulin (detto Paolo), GOZLUGOL Husevin, MARA Armando e
SEN Ramazan, D´AMBROSIO Francesco, ALBERGA Vito, OTTOMANO Vito,
COSCIA Michele, MELE Vito, DI PIERRO Mario e FUMAROLA Giovanni
al risarcimento dei danni patiti dalle parti civili costituite,
fatta eccezione per Haddaji Mohammed, e con esclusione di Agrebi
Baligh e Aidi Manjoub con esclusivo riferimento a Lodeserto
Cesare e Dokaj Paulin, da liquidarsi in separato giudizio.
Condanna gli imputati al pagamento di una provvisionale pari
a € 2000 per ogni parte civile costituita, eccezion fatta per
l´Associazione Studi Giuridici sull´Immigrazione (ASGI).
Pone a carico degli imputati le spese di costituzione e
rappresentanza delle parti civili che liquida in euro 5000 per
la parte civile assistita dall´Avv. Pistelli, euro 7000 per le
parti civili assistite dall´Avv. Petrelli, euro 15000 per le
parti civili assistite dall´Avv. Petrelli, oltre IVA, CA e spese
forfetizzate come per legge.
Letto l´art. 544 comma 3 c.p.p., indica in novanta giorni il
termine per il deposito della motivazione.
Lecce, 22 luglio 2005
_____________ ____
Il Dr. Judge. Annalisa de Benedictis
0 comments:
Post a Comment